The best way to explore the island is to hire a car. Below is a list of car hire companies situated on Long Island: 

Swift Car Rental Service
Alligator Bay, Long Island
Telephone: (242) 338-8633
Fax: (242) 338-8533 

Constantakis Car Rental
Pettys, Long Island
Telephone: (242) 337-0644 

Ellen's Inn Car Rental
PO Box DC 30607
Telephone: (242) 337-1086
Fax: (242) 337-0333 

Mr T Car Rental
Deadman's Cay, Long Island
Telephone/Fax: (242) 337-1054
 
Ophelia's Rent-A-Car
Deadman's Cay, Long Island
Telephone/Fax: (242) 337-1042

Stan's Car Rental
Miller's, Long Island
Telephone: (242) 338-8987

William's Car Rental
Glintons, Long Island
Telephone: (242) 338-5002
Fax: (242) 338-5001

Adderley's Automobile Renting & Leasing
Millers, Long Island
Telephone: (242) 338-8989 

Hamilton's Inn Car Rental
Hamilton's, Long Island
Telephone: (242) 337-1264